Love at first bite.

Handcrafted with the finest and freshest ingredients.

SERVING ALL WESTCHESTER, FAIRFIELD CT & NEW YORK CITY AREAS

NEW!

Tiramisu

The Italian Classic! Decadent and delicious!

Savoiardi cookies, mascarpone cheese, heavy cream, cane sugar, egg yolks, espresso, rum, vanilla extract, cocoa powder.

9x13 Tray | Starting at $60 (Serves 12-16)
8x8 Tray | Starting at $40 (Serves 8-10)

Place an Order

New Flavors Available!

Limoncello, Pistachio & Nutella

Apple Coffee Cake

Tender, sweet, and filled with cozy fall flavors. It’s best eaten in your PJ’s standing at the kitchen counter with your second cup of coffee!

All-purpose flour, brown sugar, powdered sugar, baking soda, baking powder, salt, nutmeg, cinnamon, ginger, allspice, vanilla extract, eggs, maple syrup, milk, applesauce, unsalted butter, fresh apples.

Serves 8 | $28

Place an Order

Baked Mini Apple Cider Donuts

These light, airy, fluffy beauties are the perfect compliment to your morning coffee on a crisp autumn day.

All-purpose flour, granulated sugar, brown sugar, baking powder, salt, cinnamon, ginger, cloves, nutmeg, eggs, unsalted butter, apple cider, apple sauce, sour cream.

1 Dozen | $17

Place an Order

Bringing joy to the masses in Westchester, Cindy Fegan provides excellence, sophistication and decadent desserts to enjoy.

Phone

(914) 374.2616

Location

West Harrison, New York

TESTIMONALS

  • Cindy’s baked goods are absolutely incredible… they beat any bakery in town hands down. I also love that she has added healthier options to her menu! Cindy is also incredibly easy to work with and I can always rely on her to create perfect treats for any occasion. Try Simply Sweet by Cindy… you won’t be disappointed!

    -Steph S.

  • I’ve enjoyed Simply Sweet by Cindy’s baked goods for years. Everything from decadent treats to healthy protein bars, all with great wholesome ingredients. Can’t wait for the next batch!

    -Mike B

  • Once you try anything from Simply Sweet by Cindy you will never go anywhere else again! Her brownies and cookies are always perfect. The seasonal menu is inventive and delicious. Last buy nut least she knows how to use Nutella! The Nutella stuffed chocolate chip cookies, ice cream and stuffed rice Krispie treats are our family’s favorites!

    -Erika L.

  • Where do I begin?!… the Nutella chocolate chip cookies are my favorite, throw in some pumpkin bread, Oreo brownies, seriously I can’t resist ANYTHING that Cindy makes. Whether I’m taking a box of baked goods home for a holiday or munching at the office, I’m so glad Cindy shares her talent with us!! Extra brownie points for having healthier options like the protein balls and gluten/vegan free items for your family. I will be ordering again soon!

    - Letizia C

  • Everything Cindy makes is so good. Whether cookies or donuts, I like that the goods are truly sweet but not too sweet. Seasonal items are perfect for the holidays - my wife loved when I surprised her with the chocolate truffles for Valentine’s Day. Thank you Cindy!

    -Nick C.

Gift Card Gift Card Gift Card Gift Card Gift Card Gift Card
Gift Card
from $25.00

A gift certificate from Simply Sweet makes the perfect gift for any occasion!

AdobeStock_402709890.jpeg
AdobeStock_326555538.jpeg
ice-cream.jpg
AdobeStock_298596574.jpeg
AdobeStock_188164980.jpeg
AdobeStock_292057481.jpeg
wide-selective-closeup-shot-stack-baked-chocolate-cookies.jpg
AdobeStock_79482829.jpeg
chocolate-ice-cream-texture.jpg

Sweet, but not too sweet.

  • Cookies

    Made lovingly with only the finest and freshest ingredients. Seasonal flavors are available upon request. Vegan & Gluten-Free options are also available.

    COOKIES

  • Brownies & Bars

    Truly one of the most versatile desserts, our brownies and blondies will be sure to please and have you asking for more. They also go great A La Mode so get some ice cream while you’re at it!

    BROWNIES

  • Cereal Treats

    Our cereal treats are a great way to satisfy that sweet tooth without having something too heavy and decadent.

    CEREAL TREATS

We offer a variety of nutritious protein bars, energy balls and healthier cookies. They are crafted with wholesome ingredients and do not contain any refined sugar or unhealthy fats.

HEALTHIER OPTIONS
 

Contact Us.